What is the Polar Vortex?

The term “polar vortex” has become part of the everyday vocabulary after the widespread media coverage of the extreme cold events over the USA during the early winter of 2014. However, there is some confusion regarding what polar vortices are and how they are related to various weather events. Adam Sobel, Lorenzo Polvani, and I have written an essay to Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society clarifying what is meant by polar vortices in the atmospheric science literature and the connections with extreme weather events at the earth’s surface. The key points from this essay are below, and  here are some FAQ.

In the atmospheric science literature, the term “polar vortex” is most commonly used as an abbreviation for “circumpolar vortex”, and refers to a planetary-scale flow that encircles the pole in middle or high latitudes. There are polar vortices in Earth’s atmosphere as well the atmospheres of other planetary bodies. Although Earth’s polar vortices are sometimes described as extending from the middle troposphere to the upper stratosphere, there are distinct tropospheric and stratospheric vortices, as illustrated schematically below.

vortex-schematic

The existence distinct tropospheric and stratospheric vortices can be easily seen in plots of the climatological zonal-mean zonal winds shown below. The latitude at which the zonal wind reaches its hemispheric maximum can be considered as marking the approximate edge of a polar vortex, and there is a clear vertical discontinuity in this latitude around 100 hPa, It is also clear that the vortex in the troposphere is much larger than the vortex in the stratosphere, and that the two are not directly connected. Furthermore, while the tropospheric vortex exists all year, the stratospheric polar vortex exists only from fall to spring.

Screen Shot 2016-03-14 at 3.49.07 PM

Both the tropospheric and stratospheric polar vortices are basic features of the earth’s climatology. There existence is neither unusual nor a manifestation of major changes in the global atmospheric circulation.

See below for more information on the stratospheric polar vortex, tropospheric polar vortex, and their connections with extreme weather events.   Also, some history, and examples of polar vortices on other planets.

Stratospheric polar vortex

[For full details see PDF Document: Waugh, D.W. and L.M. Polvani, Stratospheric Polar Vortices, in “The Stratosphere: Dynamics, Transport and Chemistry. A festschrift celebrating Alan Pumb’s 60th birthday”, L.M. Polvani, A.H. Sobel and D.W. Waugh, Eds., American Geophysical Union, Washington, D.C., 2010.]

The strong circumpolar westerlies that define the stratospheric polar vortex maximize at around 60o latitude, from just above the tropopause (~100 hPa) into the mesosphere (above 1 hPa)  (see plot of zonal winds above). The stratospheric polar vortex forms in fall when there is no solar heating in polar regions (and large-scale meridional temperature gradients), strengthens during winter, and then breaks down (and high latitude winds become weak easterlies) as sunlight returns to the polar regions in spring.

The larger topographic and land-sea contrasts in the NH generate stronger upward propagating waves than in the SH, causing the Northern stratospheric vortex to be weaker and more distorted than its Southern counterpart.  This has major implications for stratospheric ozone depletion: An ozone hole forms over Antarctica and not over the Arctic as the SH polar vortex is colder and air within it more isolated than the NH vortex.

pvseq

The dynamics of the polar vortices is best examined using potential vorticity (PV). The vortex is defined by the region of high PV, and maps of PV show the structure and evolution of the vortex. E.g., in this animation the blue areas have high absolute value of PV and identify the Antarctic polar vortex  (Courtesy of Sean Winkler‘s web site; click for animation).

crista-anim

The vortex can also be seen in maps of trace constituents, e.g.,  CRISTA measurements of nitrous oxide mixing ratios at a pressure-altitude of 10 hPa (about 30 km) (From Michael McIntyre’s web site; click for animation).

Further illustrations of the Antarctic polar vortices can be seen in images of column-integrated ozone. The image below contrasts the ozone hole between September 2001 and 2002. The 2001 situation is the normal conditions, whereas 2002 shows the rare occurrence of a sudden warming when large scale wave activity split the polar vortex, and ozone hole, into two sections.

ozone_2001_2002.

Tropospheric polar vortex

The edge of the tropospheric polar vortex is traditionally defined as specified geopotential contours, on the 300 or 500 hPa pressure levels, that typically lie within the core of the westerlies. The values of the contours chosen vary, but the tropospheric vortex edge generally lies between 40-50 degrees latitude (see bold contour in left panel below). On monthly or longer time scales Northern Hemisphere tropospheric vortex generally has two centers, one near Baffin Island and the other over northeast Siberia (left panel below). Analogous circumpolar asymmetry is not usually observed in the climatological Southern Hemisphere vortex.   The tropospheric vortex can (as in the stratosphere) be defined from potential vorticity contours on an isentropic surface. The 300-500 hPa geopotential height contours used to define the vortex are similar to the intersection of the PV = 2 or 3 PVU surface – commonly used to define the dynamical tropopause in the extratropics – with the 320 or 330K isentropic surfaces (right below).

Screen Shot 2016-03-14 at 8.37.00 PM

Maps illustrating the  tropospheric vortex in January 2014. The left panel show the geopotential height (shading) and zonal winds (white contours for 30, 40, 50, and 60 m/s) at 300 hPa, and right panel show potential vorticity at 330K. The bold black contours illustrate the edge of the vortices defined using geopotential height or potential vorticity.  Data Source: NCEP Reanalyses

On daily time scales the tropospheric vortex may have several centers, and may be distorted by “synoptic-scale” Rossby waves that propagate along the vortex edge, see figure and discussion in the next section.

Connection with Extreme Weather Events

The image below is for the cold air event over the eastern USA in early January 2014, which brought the term “polar vortex” into the general public’s vocabulary. That event was the result of a large-amplitude ridge-trough system over the USA, with the trough bringing extremely cold air south over the eastern USA on 6 January (“T” in above plots).  Although often attributed to the movement of the whole polar vortex, this event cannot be directly attributed to changes in the stratospheric vortex, or even to hemispheric changes to the tropospheric vortex. However, it may be appropriate to describe it in terms of waves on the edge of the tropospheric vortex, and the deformation of part of that vortex  (or “a lobe”) over the eastern US on 6 January, as shown in image below.

Screen Shot 2016-03-14 at 8.37.36 PM

Maps of 300 hPa geopotential height for 3 to 8 January 2014. Black contours mark the tropospheric vortex edge at 300 hPa and white contours mark the stratospheric vortex edge at 50 hPa. The “R” and “T” on 5 and 6 January indicate the location of ridge and trough discussed in the text. Data Source: NCEP Reanalyses.

History: Scientific Literature and AMS Glossary

The earliest scientific papers describing the broad-scale tropospheric or stratospheric flow as a “circumpolar vortex” or “polar vortex” are from the late 1940s and early 1950s. (Although a much earlier usage appears on pg 430 of Littell’s Living Age Map, 12 November 1853.) This is the case for both the tropospheric circumpolar vortex (e.g., Rossby and Willet 1948, LaSeur 1954) and the stratospheric circumpolar vortex (e.g., Brasefeld 1950, Palmer 1959).  The term “polar vortex” is very common in stratospheric literature with scientific interest in the stratospheric polar vortices increased dramatically in the mid-1980s because of their importance for stratospheric ozone depletion. In contrast, the term “polar vortex” is much less common in the tropospheric literature, with usage generally limited to climatology studies, e.g., series of papers by Angell and co-authors from 1970s to 2000s (see Angell 2006 and references therein).

The description of a polar vortex has varied in the American Meteorological Society Glossary of Meteorology. The original 1959 version refers only to a vortex in the middle and upper troposphere, while the 2000 and 2014 versions refer to a vortex extending from the middle troposphere to the stratosphere. The current (2015) version correctly describes distinct tropospheric and stratospheric circumpolar vortices.

Angell, J. K., 2006: Changes in the 300-mb North Circumpolar Vortex, 1963–2001, J Climate, 19, 2984-2995.
Brasefield, C. J. (1950). Winds and temperatures in the lower stratosphere. Journal of Meteorology, 7(1), 66-69.
LaSeur, N. E., On the asymmetry of the middle-latitude circumpolar current, J. Meteorol., 11, 43–75, 1954.
Palmer, C. E. (1959). The stratospheric polar vortex in winter. Journal of Geophysical Research, 64(7), 749-764.
Rossby, C.G. and Willett, H. C., 1948: The circulation of the upper troposphere and lower stratosphere,  Science, 108, 643-–652.

Planetary Polar Vortices

Polar vortices are not unique to Earth’s atmosphere. There are polar vortices in the atmospheres of many planetary bodies including Mars, Venus, Saturn, and Saturn’s moon Titan. I have done some research examining the Martian polar vortices.

Map of Potential Vorticity on 300 K isentropic surface for winter solstice, showing Mars annular polar vortex

See Emily Lakdawalla’s blog for images/animations of the other polar vortices.